04: Episode 4 : Deviated by Trump - Task
analysis
29 January 2007This week,
game started when Surya joined Arrow. At first I was
thinking, why did the transfer occurred at night as usually,
when team is largely unequal, they got to pick before the
game started. Then I realize that they (the production) had
to do that to maintain the 'have' and 'have not' theme.
Because they do have gap after the
task and before the result of winning team was announced, so
it is much worse to show Surya move to the other team on that
time. Okay.
This episode is great. I love the
fact that Arrow won. But I hate the editing. Why? There's
not much that we can see along the task. Before they started
the task, it took 1 0 minutes including part where Heidi try
to motivate her teammates. I'm fine with it but when it
reduce the airtime of the task, it kinda frustrate me a
little bit.
Usually, what we see is what we
get. We see Aaron's team did some banner, get some order,
Surya asked Aaron to call Frank and Tim back to help as the
place getting crowded. That's good enough. But how about
Heidi's team? Not much. We see some problem that Marisa
done. That's it. We can't really see what happen in the
process of selling. Is there a lot of people. I know I
demand too much by asking for this, as it's not just about
the task.
But I just checked out Apprentice
Official Site and there's a deleted scene entitled Tardy
Twosome: Derek and Marisa Late to Training (Deleted,
Week 4), showing Derek and Marisa came late to the training,
which might be the reason they ended being in marketing
team. My point is, as a viewer I love to have options of who
should be fired. It's not affecting the result, but I guess,
again as a viewer, I feel satisfied when I make the right
guess of who should be fired. Since episode 2, it's pretty
obvious of who's the trouble in the team.
For people who haven't watch the
clip, I describe about it a little bit. The clip show Derek
and Marissa came late to the training (yeah, the title speak
for itself). But it's not just about being late. They are
also disallowed from playing with the cash and order
machine. From a viewer perspective, I think that this team
lose a lot of manpower because of that. Regardless the fact
that they had enough of people at the counter, if something
turn out, the place get crowded for example, this could be a
major case.
Well, I wrote paragraphs just made
my point about showing more minutes of task being played
out. Now let's get real to the task analysis.
Why do Heidi's team lost? I won't
say that they lost because they don't think out of box. But
they lost because they don't even think in the box itself.
How does it happen?
Remember when Donald Trump
introducing a task. He will be talk about something behind
it. Like talking about how much a product gross value over
America, or what is the place significant for. This time,
Trump told them about automobile and how people did a lot of
jobs using their vehicles. And he said that the drive-thru
restaurant has been a tremendous business (I'm copying what
he said)
Good.
And then the manager of the chicken
shop told what the task is all about. At the end, he said
that the team that sell the most of their new version of
that chicken stuff win. So, what is the deal with those
introduction of automobile and drive-thru restaurant?
This is the point where Kinetic
miss. They was orientated to think that this task has
something to do with the drive-thru thingy. That's why we
can see how Kinetic put their effort on the drive-thru path.
They gave sample. And you can see two persons doing that
job.
Arrow on the other hand wasn't
deviated by what Trum p
said at the beginning so they are focusing on their sales.
You can see how Aaron didn't really care about the queue in
the drive-thru section. Because logically, you can see that
they will surely be more people in the restaurant, having
ordinary order than the customers in the drive-thru. So, it's
wasting time to force, or in more polite word, insist the
customer in drive-thru to buy the product while they can
simply let the customer in the restaurant have the sample
(and avoid waiting outside, feeling hot).
So at the end, Kinetic actually
didn't make any great effort of marketing. Who to blame? I
believe Heidi is up to blame for that lose. No strategy.
Just sell.
You see what Tim and Frank did? I
guess it's overrated to say that selling 20 product at one
spot as a big deal. Not about the number, but their selling
technique is questionable. Imagine if someone like them came
into your office/house and ask you whether you want to buy a
grill chicken product. He didn't give you any sample and you
don't really know what are you buying. Will you get it. No,
except if those guys followed by a cameraman with a big
video camera on his shoulder (not the one that we have for
our home video), then we might say yes as we are pretty
excited to imagine we are gonna appear on tv. Well, if
that's not general case, it maybe me. But at least it works
for the other 20 customers.
At the end of the day, Arrow
deserved to win and Heidi deserved to be fired for not
thinking even in the box. But Marisa was fired for being too
annoying.
Pick of the week:
Aaron
Bad to good impression: Frank & Tim
Good to bad impression: Heidi
Cute personality : Muna
Started to appear on screen: Derek
(the one with Marisa, remember) &
Surya
Who are they?: Aimee, Angela,
Kristine, Jenn
#
More of The Apprentice 6?
Go to
Sirlinksalot: The Apprentice 6
Feedback?
Email me at flexin_am (at) yahoo.com . Replace (at) with @
sign. |